Plum Island Grille

Plum Island Grille
2 Plum Island Turnpike, Newburyport, MA 01951-2035, USA
(978) 463-2290


Kathleen McDonough

Sunday, April 22, 2018

Stopped here on our weekend away for a drink on St Patty's day. We got here early and sat at the bar. The bartender was attentive and the drinks were good. My husband just had a Sam Adams and I tried their blood orange martini which was on the menu. It was tasty. We decided to order an appetizer and tried the lamb meatballs and the bartender made me a special drink a lemodrop with blueberries. When they can out I cracked open to find it was completely raw in the middle. The bartender quickly scooped them up apologized and said I'll get you some new ones. The second set came out and the were also raw, but not was bad. She ended up taking them off the bill. Drinks were great though and so was the bartender!!

Donkey007 A Family Guy

Friday, April 20, 2018

Good service, clean restroom, good food, very good food, very nice people, just not AMAZING...

Amber Everin

Saturday, Dec. 2, 2017

Adorable little place just happened to stop at while passing through. Staff was super friendly, drinks were good, food was delish. View was super pretty with the sun setting. I highly recommend and love off season times to tour around

Yan Ge

Sunday, Jan. 14, 2018

Nice seafood chowder, run into a night with special on half price appetizers. Looks like a very cozy Cheers-ish local hangout place.

Nauti Tackle

Tuesday, June 20, 2017

OVER PRICED!!! Disgusting food! The place is hot and loud. They have ceiling fans hanging with a blade missing we asked to turn the fan on however it was impossible because the fan was hitting the ceiling vent. I believe it was $10 for a caesar salad with anchovies however they didn't bring my anchovies when I asked for them they brought one. Very small servings (not that it matters because it's not edible anyway) but I got an attitude for asking for anchovies. I had to beg for dressing because I got a plate full of lettuce. The clams with linguine was so bland I think they poured hot water in a bowl of pasta and added couple clams. The pork chop just as bland as the clam linguine. I would not go back to this place if it was free food horrible horrible horrible!!!